| | | Carthage wins toss, defers. Wheaton will receive and defend east end. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage30 | CARTHAGE ball on CARTHAGE30. |
| | | Krause,Kurt kickoff 66 yards to the WHEATON4, Antal return 21 yards to the WHEATON25 (Kaput,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton25 | Roberts pass incomplete to Zoerhof, QB hurry by Dorau,Nick. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Wheaton25 | Clock 14:49, Gingg rush for loss of 2 yards to the WHEATON23 (Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 3-12 | at Wheaton23 | Clock 14:19, Roberts pass incomplete to Ellis. |
| Wheaton | 4-12 | at Wheaton23 | Vargyas punt 33 yards to the CARTHAGE44, fair catch by Schulz,Chris. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage44 | CARTHAGE drive start at 14:04. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage44 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 10 yards to the WHEATON46, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE, out-of-bounds (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Wheaton46 | Clock 13:49, Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Schulz,Chris. |
| Carthage | 2-10 | at Wheaton46 | Smith,Jake rush for 2 yards to the WHEATON44 (Jacobson). |
| Carthage | 3-8 | at Wheaton44 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 38 yards to the WHEATON6, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Shaw). |
| Carthage | 1-G | at Wheaton06 | Miller,Reggie rush for loss of 4 yards to the WHEATON10 (McMullen;Driggers). |
| Carthage | 2-G | at Wheaton10 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Djurickovic, P (Jacobson). |
| Carthage | 3-G | at Wheaton10 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 5 yards to the WHEATON5 (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 4-G | at Wheaton05 | Funk,Tyler field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 11:12. |
| | | Carthage 3, Wheaton College 0 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 51 yards, TOP 02:52 |
| | | Krause,Kurt kickoff 67 yards to the WHEATON3, Antal return 27 yards to the WHEATON30 (O'Brien,Casey). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton30 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 11:12. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton30 | Jarrett rush for loss of 2 yards to the WHEATON28. |
| Wheaton | 2-12 | at Wheaton28 | PENALTY WHEATON false start 5 yards to the WHEATON23. |
| Wheaton | 2-17 | at Wheaton23 | Ellis rush for 7 yards to the WHEATON30 (Brennan,Josh), PENALTY CARTHAGE sideline interference 5 yards to the WHEATON35. |
| Wheaton | 2-5 | at Wheaton35 | 2nd and 5. |
| Wheaton | 2-5 | at Wheaton35 | Jarrett rush for no gain to the WHEATON35 (Southern,L;Graves,Sean). |
| Wheaton | 3-5 | at Wheaton35 | Clock 09:22, Roberts pass complete to Zeller for 18 yards to the CARTHAGE47, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Brennan,Josh;Bolden,Wayne). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage47 | Jarrett rush for loss of 2 yards to the CARTHAGE49 (Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 2-12 | at Carthage49 | Jarrett rush for 20 yards to the CARTHAGE29, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Southern,L). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage29 | PENALTY WHEATON personal foul 15 yards to the CARTHAGE44. |
| Wheaton | 1-25 | at Carthage44 | 1st and 10. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage44 | Jarrett rush for no gain to the CARTHAGE44 (Radke,Cory;Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Carthage44 | Roberts sacked for loss of 3 yards to the CARTHAGE47 (Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 3-13 | at Carthage47 | Roberts rush for 25 yards to the CARTHAGE22, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Jordan,T.J.;Solis,Erik), PENALTY CARTHAGE personal foul 11 yards to the CARTHAGE11, 1ST DOWN WHEATON. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage11 | 1st and 10. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage11 | Roberts pass complete to Zeller for 11 yards to the CARTHAGE0, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:30. |
| | | Roche kick attempt good. |
| | | Wheaton College 7, Carthage 3 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 70 yards, TOP 04:42 |
| | | Roche kickoff 70 yards to the CARTHAGE0, Bolden,Wayne return 22 yards to the CARTHAGE22 (Hart;Dansdill). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage22 | CARTHAGE drive start at 06:30. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage22 | Smith,Jake rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE25 (Dougan). |
| Carthage | 2-7 | at Carthage25 | Clock 05:50, Trepanier, T.J. pass incomplete to Lukas,Tim. |
| Carthage | 3-7 | at Carthage25 | Trepanier, T.J. pass incomplete to Koeneman,Mike. |
| Carthage | 4-7 | at Carthage25 | Funk,Tyler punt 30 yards to the WHEATON45, out-of-bounds, PENALTY CARTHAGE illegal procedure 5 yards to the 50 yardline, 1st and 10, WHEATON ball on 50 yardline. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:40 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton50 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 05:50. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton50 | PENALTY WHEATON false start 5 yards to the WHEATON45. |
| Wheaton | 1-15 | at Wheaton45 | Skogen,J rush for 7 yards to the CARTHAGE48 (O'Brien,Casey). |
| Wheaton | 2-8 | at Carthage48 | Roberts pass complete to Skogen,J for 16 yards to the CARTHAGE32, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Solis,Erik). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage32 | Antal rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE31 (Bolden,Wayne). |
| Wheaton | 2-9 | at Carthage31 | Roberts pass complete to Gingg for 9 yards to the CARTHAGE22, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Alvarez,Andre). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage22 | Skogen,J rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE20 (Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 2-8 | at Carthage20 | Clock 03:05, Skogen,J rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE17 (Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 3-5 | at Carthage17 | Roberts pass incomplete to Antal (Alvarez,Andre), QB hurry by Radke,Cory. |
| Wheaton | 4-5 | at Carthage17 | Roche field goal attempt from 34 MISSED - wide left, spot at CARTHAGE20, clock 02:18. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 33 yards, TOP 03:32 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | CARTHAGE drive start at 02:18. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Smith,Jake for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE23 (Chapman). |
| Carthage | 2-7 | at Carthage23 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 5 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (Chapman). |
| Carthage | 3-2 | at Carthage28 | Clock 01:20, Jones,Evan pass complete to Djurickovic, P for 44 yards to the WHEATON28, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Langs, T). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Wheaton28 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for 21 yards to the WHEATON7, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (McMullen). |
| Carthage | 1-G | at Wheaton07 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for 7 yards to the WHEATON0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:56. |
| | | Funk,Tyler kick attempt good. |
| | | Carthage 10, Wheaton College 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 80 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| | | Krause,Kurt kickoff 63 yards to the WHEATON7, Markley return 21 yards to the WHEATON28 (O'Brien,Casey). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton28 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 00:56. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton28 | Roberts pass complete to Antal for 16 yards to the WHEATON44, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton44 | Clock 00:36, Roberts pass incomplete to Zeller (Solis,Erik). |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Wheaton44 | Gingg rush for 4 yards to the WHEATON48 (Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 3-6 | at Wheaton48 | Gingg rush for no gain to the WHEATON48 (Brennan,Josh). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 01:05 |
| | | Carthage 10, Wheaton College 7 |
| Wheaton | 4-6 | at Wheaton48 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wheaton | 4-6 | at Wheaton48 | Vargyas punt 35 yards to the CARTHAGE17, Schulz,Chris return 8 yards to the CARTHAGE25 (McBroom;East). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 01:05 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage25 | CARTHAGE drive start at 14:51. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage25 | Trepanier, T.J. rush for 15 yards to the CARTHAGE40, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | Smith,Jake rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE41 (Ramsay,R;Chapman). |
| Carthage | 2-9 | at Carthage41 | Smith,Jake rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE43 (Driggers;Ramsay,R). |
| Carthage | 3-7 | at Carthage43 | Clock 13:23, Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Schulz,Chris, QB hurry by Ramsay,R. |
| Carthage | 4-7 | at Carthage43 | Funk,Tyler punt 36 yards to the WHEATON21, Langs, T return 4 yards to the WHEATON25 (Fortney,Brad;McNeiece,James). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:45 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton25 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 13:06. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton25 | Roberts pass incomplete to Watkins, QB hurry by Brennan,Josh. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Wheaton25 | Jarrett rush for loss of 1 yard to the WHEATON24 (Dorau,Nick;Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 3-11 | at Wheaton24 | Roberts pass incomplete to Jarrett, QB hurry by Merucci,Mike. |
| Wheaton | 4-11 | at Wheaton24 | Vargyas punt 36 yards to the CARTHAGE40, fair catch by Schulz,Chris. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:48 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | CARTHAGE drive start at 12:18. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | Smith,Jake rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE42, out-of-bounds (Driggers;McMullen). |
| Carthage | 2-8 | at Carthage42 | Clock 11:35, Smith,Jake rush for 7 yards to the CARTHAGE49 (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 3-1 | at Carthage49 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for 37 yards to the WHEATON14, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Langs, J;Langs, T). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Wheaton14 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Popp,Matt for 14 yards to the WHEATON0, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:42. |
| | | Funk,Tyler kick attempt good. |
| | | Carthage 17, Wheaton College 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 60 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| | | Krause,Kurt kickoff 57 yards to the WHEATON13, Ellis return 14 yards to the WHEATON27 (Oratowski,Mike). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton27 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 10:42. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton27 | Clock 10:37, Roberts pass complete to Ellis for 72 yards to the CARTHAGE1, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Bolden,Wayne). |
| Wheaton | 1-G | at Carthage01 | Roberts pass intercepted by Hipchen,Brian at the CARTHAGE0, Hipchen,Brian return 0 yards to the CARTHAGE0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 72 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | CARTHAGE drive start at 09:50. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE21 (McBroom;VanHeest). |
| Carthage | 2-9 | at Carthage21 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Lukas,Tim for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE24 (Langs, T;Chapman). |
| Carthage | 3-6 | at Carthage24 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Koeneman,Mike (Chapman). |
| Carthage | 4-6 | at Carthage24 | Funk,Tyler punt 51 yards to the WHEATON25, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton25 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 08:44. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton25 | Roberts pass complete to Watkins for 6 yards to the WHEATON31, out-of-bounds (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 2-4 | at Wheaton31 | Ellis rush for 1 yard to the WHEATON32 (Solis,Erik;O'Brien,Tyler). |
| Wheaton | 3-3 | at Wheaton32 | Timeout Carthage, clock 07:41. |
| Wheaton | 3-3 | at Wheaton32 | Skogen,J rush for 2 yards to the WHEATON34 (Graves,Sean;Hogen,Brett). |
| Wheaton | 4-1 | at Wheaton34 | Vargyas punt 39 yards to the CARTHAGE27, Schulz,Chris return 13 yards to the CARTHAGE40 (Driggers;McBroom). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:54 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | CARTHAGE drive start at 06:50. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | Smith,Jake rush for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE44 (Dougan;Mitchell,C). |
| Carthage | 2-6 | at Carthage44 | Smith,Jake rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE47 (Jacobson;Chapman). |
| Carthage | 3-3 | at Carthage47 | Clock 05:48, Jones,Evan pass complete to Popp,Matt for 13 yards to the WHEATON40, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Langs, J), PENALTY WHEATON pass interference declined. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Wheaton40 | 1st and 10. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Wheaton40 | Trepanier, T.J. pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 40 yards to the WHEATON0, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:31. |
| | | Funk,Tyler kick attempt good. |
| | | Carthage 24, Wheaton College 7 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 60 yards, TOP 01:19 |
| | | Krause,Kurt kickoff 64 yards to the WHEATON6, Ellis return 33 yards to the WHEATON39 (Solis,Erik;Kaput,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton39 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 05:31. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton39 | Gingg rush for 4 yards to the WHEATON43 (Jordan,T.J.;Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 2-6 | at Wheaton43 | Roberts pass complete to Zeller for 42 yards to the CARTHAGE15 (Brennan,Josh), PENALTY WHEATON pass interference 15 yards to the WHEATON28, NO PLAY. |
| Wheaton | 2-21 | at Wheaton28 | Clock 04:43, Roberts rush for 18 yards to the WHEATON46 (Solis,Erik). |
| Wheaton | 3-3 | at Wheaton46 | Clock 04:31, Gingg rush for 3 yards to the WHEATON49, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Jauch,Kelly). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton49 | Clock 04:11, Gingg rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE49 (Brennan,Josh;Radke,Cory). |
| Wheaton | 2-8 | at Carthage49 | Roberts pass complete to Zoerhof for 15 yards to the CARTHAGE34, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage34 | Clock 03:30, Roberts pass incomplete to Antal, QB hurry by Radke,Cory. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Carthage34 | PENALTY WHEATON false start 5 yards to the CARTHAGE39. |
| Wheaton | 2-15 | at Carthage39 | Roberts rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE36, out-of-bounds (Southern,L;Jordan,T.J.). |
| Wheaton | 3-12 | at Carthage36 | Timeout Wheaton College, clock 02:52. |
| Wheaton | 3-12 | at Carthage36 | Roberts pass incomplete to Ellis (Hipchen,Brian), QB hurry by Merucci,Mike. |
| Wheaton | 4-12 | at Carthage36 | Vargyas punt 36 yards to the CARTHAGE0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 25 yards, TOP 02:50 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | CARTHAGE drive start at 02:41. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | Miller,Reggie rush for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE24 (Langs, T;Jacobson). |
| Carthage | 2-6 | at Carthage24 | Clock 02:05, Jones,Evan pass complete to Snell,Kyle for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (McBroom). |
| Carthage | 3-2 | at Carthage28 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Koeneman,Mike (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 4-2 | at Carthage28 | Funk,Tyler punt 42 yards to the WHEATON30, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton30 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 01:16. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton30 | Roberts pass complete to Jarrett for 11 yards to the WHEATON41, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Jauch,Kelly;Radke,Cory). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton41 | Roberts pass complete to Watkins for 3 yards to the WHEATON44 (Southern,L;Hartwig,Hank). |
| Wheaton | 2-7 | at Wheaton44 | Roberts pass complete to Ellis for 26 yards to the CARTHAGE30, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, out-of-bounds (Southern,L). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage30 | Clock 00:29, Roberts pass incomplete to Antal, QB hurry by Jordan,T.J.. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Carthage30 | Clock 00:24, Roberts rush for 12 yards to the CARTHAGE18, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, out-of-bounds (Hogen,Brett). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | Roberts pass complete to Watkins for 5 yards to the CARTHAGE13, out-of-bounds (Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 2-5 | at Carthage13 | Clock 00:10, PENALTY CARTHAGE Encroachment 5 yards to the CARTHAGE8, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, NO PLAY. |
| Wheaton | 1-G | at Carthage08 | Clock 00:10, Roberts pass complete to Watkins for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE5 (Vitkauskas,A;Hartwig,Hank). |
| Wheaton | 2-G | at Carthage05 | Timeout Wheaton College, clock 00:04. |
| Wheaton | 2-G | at Carthage05 | Timeout Carthage, clock 00:04. |
| Wheaton | 2-G | at Carthage05 | Roche field goal attempt from 22 MISSED - wide right, spot at CARTHAGE5, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 65 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage05 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Carthage 24, Wheaton College 7 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage05 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, WHEATON ball on WHEATON30. |
| | | Roche kickoff 60 yards to the CARTHAGE10, Bolden,Wayne return 10 yards to the CARTHAGE20, fumble forced by Dansdill, fumble by Bolden,Wayne recovered by WHEATON Cook, G at CARTHAGE20. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 14:55. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage20 | Jarrett rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE19 (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 2-9 | at Carthage19 | Clock 14:20, Roberts pass complete to Skogen,J for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE17 (Brennan,Josh;Radke,Cory). |
| Wheaton | 3-7 | at Carthage17 | Roberts pass incomplete to Zoerhof. |
| Wheaton | 4-7 | at Carthage17 | PENALTY WHEATON delay of game 5 yards to the CARTHAGE22. |
| Wheaton | 4-12 | at Carthage22 | Roche field goal attempt from 39 MISSED - wide right, spot at CARTHAGE22, clock 13:37. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:18 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage22 | CARTHAGE drive start at 13:37. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage22 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Koeneman,Mike (Langs, T). |
| Carthage | 2-10 | at Carthage22 | Clock 13:30, Jones,Evan pass complete to Smith,Jake for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE24 (Mitchell,C). |
| Carthage | 3-8 | at Carthage24 | Clock 13:02, Jones,Evan sacked for loss of 13 yards to the CARTHAGE11 (Dougan), PENALTY CARTHAGE intentional grounding 0 yards to the CARTHAGE11. |
| Carthage | 4-21 | at Carthage11 | 4th and 21. |
| Carthage | 4-21 | at Carthage11 | Funk,Tyler punt 36 yards to the CARTHAGE47, Langs, T return 17 yards to the CARTHAGE30 (Erdmann,Alex). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 00:53 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage30 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 12:44. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage30 | Roberts rush for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE26 (Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 2-6 | at Carthage26 | Roberts pass incomplete to Gingg. |
| Wheaton | 3-6 | at Carthage26 | Roberts pass complete to Zoerhof for 26 yards to the CARTHAGE0, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:00. |
| | | Roche kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by TEAM). |
| | | Carthage 24, Wheaton College 13 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 30 yards, TOP 00:44 |
| | | Roche kickoff 64 yards to the CARTHAGE6, Bolden,Wayne return 22 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (McBroom). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage28 | CARTHAGE drive start at 12:00. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage28 | Smith,Jake rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE30 (Dougan). |
| Carthage | 2-8 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for loss of 2 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (Dougan;Chapman). |
| Carthage | 3-10 | at Carthage28 | Clock 10:47, Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Lukas,Tim. |
| Carthage | 4-10 | at Carthage28 | Funk,Tyler punt 38 yards to the WHEATON34, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton34 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 10:28. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton34 | Roberts pass complete to Ellis for loss of 1 yard to the WHEATON33 (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 2-11 | at Wheaton33 | Jarrett rush for 10 yards to the WHEATON43 (Vitkauskas,A;Jauch,Kelly). |
| | | Injury timeout. |
| Wheaton | 3-1 | at Wheaton43 | Roberts rush for 2 yards to the WHEATON45, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (TEAM). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton45 | Roberts pass complete to Zoerhof for 11 yards to the CARTHAGE44, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, out-of-bounds (Bolden,Wayne). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage44 | Roberts pass incomplete to Antal (Vitkauskas,A), QB hurry by Graves,Sean. |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Carthage44 | Clock 08:50, Jarrett rush for no gain to the CARTHAGE44 (Jauch,Kelly;Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 3-10 | at Carthage44 | Roberts rush for 11 yards to the CARTHAGE33, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, out-of-bounds (Merucci,Mike), PENALTY CARTHAGE face mask (Hogen,Brett) 15 yards to the CARTHAGE18, 1ST DOWN WHEATON. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | 1st and 10. |
| | | Game was delayed 27 minutes by lightning |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | Clock 07:58. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | Roberts rush for 5 yards to the CARTHAGE13 (Dorau,Nick;Hogen,Brett). |
| Wheaton | 2-5 | at Carthage13 | Gingg rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE12 (Fortney,Brad;Brennan,Josh). |
| Wheaton | 3-4 | at Carthage12 | Roberts pass complete to Zoerhof for 12 yards to the CARTHAGE0, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:50. |
| | | Roberts pass attempt failed. |
| | | Carthage 24, Wheaton College 19 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 66 yards, TOP 03:38 |
| | | Roche kickoff 60 yards to the CARTHAGE10, Bolden,Wayne return 15 yards to the CARTHAGE25 (Dansdill;Hart). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage25 | CARTHAGE drive start at 06:50. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage25 | Smith,Jake rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (Ramsay,R;East). |
| Carthage | 2-7 | at Carthage28 | Jones,Evan rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE30, QB hurry by Ramsay,R. |
| Carthage | 3-5 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Koeneman,Mike (McMullen). |
| Carthage | 4-5 | at Carthage30 | Funk,Tyler punt 40 yards to the WHEATON30, Langs, T return 7 yards to the WHEATON37 (Fortney,Brad). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:03 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton37 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 05:47. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton37 | Roberts pass complete to Watkins for 11 yards to the WHEATON48, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton48 | Clock 05:30, Roberts pass complete to Ellis for 5 yards to the CARTHAGE47 (Hipchen,Brian;Alvarez,Andre). |
| Wheaton | 2-5 | at Carthage47 | Jarrett rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE45 (Fortney,Brad;O'Brien,Tyler). |
| Wheaton | 3-3 | at Carthage45 | Jarrett rush for no gain to the CARTHAGE45 (Vitkauskas,A;Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 4-3 | at Carthage45 | Vargyas punt 30 yards to the CARTHAGE15, Schulz,Chris return 1 yards to the CARTHAGE16 (McBroom). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage16 | CARTHAGE drive start at 03:18. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage16 | Jones,Evan sacked for loss of 11 yards to the CARTHAGE5 (East). |
| Carthage | 2-21 | at Carthage05 | Clock 02:35, Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 19 yards to the CARTHAGE24, out-of-bounds (Langs, J). |
| Carthage | 3-2 | at Carthage24 | Jones,Evan rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE27, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage27 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Smith,Jake for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE29 (McBroom;Chapman). |
| Carthage | 2-8 | at Carthage29 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Schulz,Chris for 6 yards to the CARTHAGE35, out-of-bounds (McBroom). |
| Carthage | 3-2 | at Carthage35 | Clock 01:20, Jones,Evan pass complete to Lukas,Tim for 10 yards to the CARTHAGE45, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Langs, T;Jacobson). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage45 | Clock 01:14, Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Lukas,Tim (McMullen). |
| Carthage | 2-10 | at Carthage45 | Jones,Evan pass intercepted by Langs, J at the WHEATON42, Langs, J return 58 yards to the CARTHAGE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:54. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 29 yards, TOP 02:24 |
| | | Roberts pass attempt failed. |
| | | Wheaton College 25, Carthage 24 |
| | | Roche kickoff 42 yards to the CARTHAGE28, Dwyer,Marty return 10 yards to the CARTHAGE38 (Foster;Burt). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage38 | CARTHAGE drive start at 00:47. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage38 | Trepanier, T.J. rush for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE41 (Chapman). |
| Carthage | 2-7 | at Carthage41 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Djurickovic, P, dropped pass. |
| Carthage | 3-7 | at Carthage41 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to McNeiece,James. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| | | Wheaton College 25, Carthage 24 |
| Carthage | 4-7 | at Carthage41 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Carthage | 4-7 | at Carthage41 | Funk,Tyler punt 37 yards to the WHEATON22, Langs, T return 38 yards to the CARTHAGE40, PENALTY WHEATON illegal block 10 yards to the 50 yardline, 1st and 10, WHEATON ball on 50 yardline. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton50 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 14:36. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton50 | Gingg rush for 6 yards to the CARTHAGE44 (Southern,L). |
| Wheaton | 2-4 | at Carthage44 | Clock 13:59, Gingg rush for 7 yards to the CARTHAGE37, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Southern,L;Jauch,Kelly). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage37 | Roberts rush for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE33, out-of-bounds (Brennan,Josh), PENALTY CARTHAGE personal foul (Brennan,Josh) 15 yards to the CARTHAGE18, 1ST DOWN WHEATON. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | 1st and 10. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage18 | Gingg rush for 8 yards to the CARTHAGE10 (Bolden,Wayne;Southern,L). |
| Wheaton | 2-2 | at Carthage10 | Roberts rush for 7 yards to the CARTHAGE3, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Southern,L;Jordan,T.J.). |
| Wheaton | 1-G | at Carthage03 | Gingg rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE2 (Jauch,Kelly). |
| Wheaton | 2-G | at Carthage02 | Roberts rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:50. |
| Wheaton | 1-G | at Carthage03 | PENALTY WHEATON false start 5 yards to the CARTHAGE8. |
| | | Roche kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Radke,Cory). |
| | | Wheaton College 31, Carthage 24 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 50 yards, TOP 02:46 |
| | | Roche kickoff 62 yards to the CARTHAGE8, Bolden,Wayne return 19 yards to the CARTHAGE27 (Foster;Shaw). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage27 | CARTHAGE drive start at 11:50. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage27 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for 3 yards to the CARTHAGE30. |
| Carthage | 2-7 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Popp,Matt. |
| Carthage | 3-7 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for loss of 2 yards to the CARTHAGE28 (Langs, T). |
| Carthage | 4-9 | at Carthage28 | Funk,Tyler punt 33 yards to the WHEATON39, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton39 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 10:29. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton39 | Roberts rush for 3 yards to the WHEATON42 (O'Brien,Tyler;Jauch,Kelly). |
| Wheaton | 2-7 | at Wheaton42 | Clock 09:56, Jarrett rush for loss of 1 yard to the WHEATON41 (O'Brien,Tyler). |
| Wheaton | 3-8 | at Wheaton41 | Roberts pass incomplete to Zoerhof. |
| Wheaton | 4-8 | at Wheaton41 | Vargyas punt 43 yards to the CARTHAGE16, Schulz,Chris return -1 yards to the CARTHAGE15 (Foster). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage15 | CARTHAGE drive start at 08:53. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage15 | Trepanier, T.J. rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE17 (East). |
| Carthage | 2-8 | at Carthage17 | Clock 08:24, Smith,Jake rush for 1 yard to the CARTHAGE18 (Chapman;Ramsay,R). |
| Carthage | 3-7 | at Carthage18 | Clock 07:52, Jones,Evan pass complete to Snell,Kyle for 12 yards to the CARTHAGE30, 1ST DOWN CARTHAGE (Jacobson). |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan pass incomplete to Djurickovic, P. |
| Carthage | 2-10 | at Carthage30 | Jones,Evan sacked for loss of 5 yards to the CARTHAGE25 (Dougan). |
| Carthage | 3-15 | at Carthage25 | Clock 07:00, Jones,Evan pass complete to Smith,Jake for 10 yards to the CARTHAGE35 (Markley). |
| Carthage | 4-5 | at Carthage35 | Funk,Tyler punt 20 yards to the WHEATON45, out-of-bounds, PENALTY CARTHAGE personal foul 15 yards to the CARTHAGE40, 1ST DOWN WHEATON, 1st and 10, WHEATON ball on CARTHAGE40. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:40 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 06:13. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage40 | Roberts pass incomplete to Clark (Hipchen,Brian). |
| Wheaton | 2-10 | at Carthage40 | PENALTY WHEATON personal foul 15 yards to the WHEATON45. |
| Wheaton | 2-25 | at Wheaton45 | Gingg rush for 4 yards to the WHEATON49 (Jauch,Kelly;Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 3-21 | at Wheaton49 | Gingg rush for 9 yards to the CARTHAGE42 (Fortney,Brad;Vitkauskas,A). |
| Wheaton | 4-12 | at Carthage42 | Vargyas punt 27 yards to the CARTHAGE15, fair catch by Schulz,Chris. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:45 |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage15 | CARTHAGE drive start at 04:28. |
| Carthage | 1-10 | at Carthage15 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Smith,Jake for loss of 4 yards to the CARTHAGE11 (East). |
| Carthage | 2-14 | at Carthage11 | Clock 04:02, Jones,Evan sacked for loss of 6 yards to the CARTHAGE5 (East). |
| Carthage | 3-20 | at Carthage05 | Jones,Evan pass complete to Koeneman,Mike for 8 yards to the CARTHAGE13 (Langs, T;Driggers). |
| Carthage | 4-12 | at Carthage13 | Funk,Tyler punt 48 yards to the WHEATON39, Langs, T return 6 yards to the WHEATON45 (Solis,Erik;Fortney,Brad). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton45 | WHEATON COLLEGE drive start at 02:39. |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Wheaton45 | Roberts rush for 7 yards to the CARTHAGE48 (Jordan,T.J.;Radke,Cory). |
| Wheaton | 2-3 | at Carthage48 | Timeout Carthage, clock 02:33. |
| Wheaton | 2-3 | at Carthage48 | Gingg rush for 4 yards to the CARTHAGE44, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Krzyzewski,M;Southern,L). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage44 | Clock 02:07, Roberts rush for 8 yards to the CARTHAGE36 (Southern,L;Krzyzewski,M). |
| Wheaton | 2-2 | at Carthage36 | Timeout Carthage, clock 02:00. |
| Wheaton | 2-2 | at Carthage36 | Roberts rush for 2 yards to the CARTHAGE34, 1ST DOWN WHEATON (Jauch,Kelly;Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 1-10 | at Carthage34 | Clock 01:28, Gingg rush for loss of 1 yard to the CARTHAGE35 (Brennan,Josh;Fortney,Brad). |
| Wheaton | 2-11 | at Carthage35 | Timeout Carthage, clock 01:22. |
| Wheaton | 2-11 | at Carthage35 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the CARTHAGE37. |
| Wheaton | 3-13 | at Carthage37 | TEAM rush for loss of 3 yards to the CARTHAGE40. |
| Wheaton | 4-16 | at Carthage40 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 15 yards, TOP 02:39 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Wheaton College 31, Carthage 24 |